Final score is calculated by weighting and averaging all datapoints across multiple categories.
The fundamental gameplay experience including fun factor, mechanics, and technical performance.
The core gameplay mechanics are highly praised for their engaging combat and deep buildcrafting, but this strong foundation is significantly undermined by persistent technical issues like crashes and bugs, leading to an inconsistent player experience.
Story quality, world depth, replay value, and overall content value.
Players find moments of quality in recent content, but this is offset by concerns over a repetitive endgame, a fragmented narrative that is difficult to follow, and the high perceived cost of expansions and monetization.
Visual and audio quality combined with creative and innovative design elements.
The game's presentation is a standout success due to its widely acclaimed visual and audio quality; however, this is tempered by a sense that recent updates lack genuine creativity, with new gameplay ideas often feeling uninspired.
Multiplayer features, social aspects, and developer support systems.
While players enjoy the cooperative social aspects, the experience is frequently hampered by unreliable matchmaking and server instability, amplified by a sentiment that developer communication and responsiveness to community feedback are inconsistent.
Our True-Review is based on 10 datapoints collected over multiple days. Each datapoint is scored and weighted according to its importance. These weighted scores are then averaged to calculate the final True-Review score.
You can look at the scores and weights and make adjustments to see where we derive the final from. Tinker, play, test and above all else - have fun!
Open Score TinkererOur reviews are based on comprehensive datapoint analysis collected over multiple days of community feedback and gameplay data. Each datapoint is scored and weighted according to its importance in the overall experience.
Learn more about our methodologyPure enjoyment and entertainment value of playing the game.
Players derive significant enjoyment from the deep buildcrafting introduced with recent content and the satisfaction of conquering difficult endgame activities with friends. However, this fun is often tempered by the perception that the seasonal model leads to repetitive activity loops and content droughts between major releases. Frustrations with certain long-standing clunky mechanics also detract from the experience, creating a divide between moments of brilliance and periods of monotony.
Quality of primary gameplay systems including combat, controls, and core interaction loops.
The game's moment-to-moment gunplay and ability usage remain a primary strength, consistently praised for feeling responsive and satisfying. Players are deeply engaged in exploring the vast buildcrafting possibilities, especially with systems expanded in 'The Edge of Fate,' to optimize their effectiveness in combat. While the core loop is exceptional, persistent audio bugs and perceived imbalances in weapon and ability tuning for certain activities are recurring points of friction that slightly tarnish an otherwise stellar mechanical foundation.
Game stability, optimization, frame rate, bugs, and overall technical execution.
A significant portion of the community reports that technical instability is severely hampering their experience, particularly in the wake of the recent 'The Edge of Fate' expansion. Frequent crashes and disruptive error codes during high-stakes activities like raids or Grandmaster Nightfalls are a major source of player frustration, often invalidating time and effort. While the game runs smoothly for some, widespread reports of frame rate drops and persistent bugs suggest that overall optimization and stability are not meeting player expectations for a mature, established title.
Overall quality of story, world-building, characters, and narrative pacing across all content.
While the quality of individual missions and cinematic moments from the recent 'The Edge of Fate' expansion is often praised, the overall narrative experience is seen as fragmented. New and returning players struggle to connect with the story due to years of vaulted campaigns and a confusing onboarding process, making it difficult to understand the stakes. This creates a significant barrier to immersion, as the excellent lore and world-building are inaccessible to those who haven't played continuously for years.
Amount of content, replayability factors, and long-term engagement potential.
The game's strong core gameplay and deep buildcrafting systems provide a solid foundation for long-term engagement, with many players continuing to chase optimized loadouts. However, a common sentiment is that the endgame grind has become repetitive and unrewarding, with players questioning the value of replaying the same core activities for marginal gains. While the promise of future expansions like 'Renegades' keeps players invested, the current loop is seen by many as lacking the compelling long-term incentives needed to make the time investment feel consistently worthwhile.
Price-to-content ratio, DLC value, microtransaction fairness, and overall monetary value.
Players are conflicted about the game's value proposition, leading to a divided sentiment on its monetization. Many feel the cost of entry for new expansions like 'The Edge of Fate,' combined with seasonal passes and the cosmetic store, represents a significant and ever-increasing financial commitment. This has led to intense community debate over whether the amount of new content provided justifies the price, especially when compared to previous years. While the core gameplay is often enjoyed, the perceived high cost to stay current is a major point of contention.
Combined assessment of graphics, art style, sound design, music, and overall presentation.
The game's presentation remains a universally acclaimed aspect of the experience, consistently drawing praise from the community. The unique art direction, stunning environmental design, and detailed weapon models create a visually captivating universe that players love to inhabit. This is complemented by an award-winning musical score and impactful sound design that elevates combat and exploration, making the overall aesthetic a primary reason for the game's enduring appeal.
Originality, fresh ideas, creative design elements, and innovative approaches to gameplay or presentation.
The community sees a great deal of creative potential in the game's universe but feels that recent execution has been inconsistent. While players often praise the conceptual ideas behind new mechanics or seasonal events, they frequently express disappointment that the final implementation feels uninspired or derivative of past content. There is a prevailing sentiment that the game has fallen into a predictable, formulaic pattern, with new systems often feeling like reskins of old ones rather than truly groundbreaking additions.
Quality of multiplayer gameplay, social features, community interaction, and online experiences.
While playing with friends and engaging in cooperative activities remains a core joy for many, the underlying social and multiplayer systems are a source of significant frustration. Players frequently criticize the unreliable matchmaking, persistent server instability, and connection errors that can ruin an otherwise fun session. Furthermore, the lack of robust in-game tools for finding groups and concerns over player behavior in competitive modes detract from the social experience, making it feel underdeveloped for a game so reliant on multiplayer.
Developer communication, update frequency, bug fixes, and overall post-launch support quality.
Player sentiment towards developer support is deeply divided, reflecting a complex and often strained relationship. While the community acknowledges and appreciates specific bug fixes and well-received events, there is a widespread feeling that broader feedback on core issues is often ignored. Persistent bugs, a perceived lack of transparency in developer communications, and controversial decisions that don't seem to respect the player's time investment are major sources of discontent, with many players feeling that the developers are not fully responsive to the community's most pressing concerns.