Soren6.10
89,826 sources over 45 days
Destiny 2 review (89.8k+ sources) scores it 6.1/10. It shines with best-in-class gunplay and stunning art, but struggles with repetitive content and outdated systems.
Share:
Review of: Destiny 2

Destiny 2: Cooperative Firefights Remain a Sci-Fi Spectacle

09-AUG-25 - 1 month ago

True-Review™ Summary

Calculated Final Score

Final score is calculated by weighting and averaging all datapoints across multiple categories.

Soren
6.10
Based on 89,826 sources
Destiny 2 stands as a titan of the live-service landscape, a game that has defined and redefined the looter-shooter genre for nearly a decade. However, in the recent weeks following the launch of its latest expansion, 'The Edge of Fate,' current player sentiment paints a picture of a beloved universe at a crossroads. While the core action that brought millions of Guardians into the fold continues to receive praise, recent community discussions highlight significant friction points regarding content depth and social infrastructure. This isn't a review of the game's entire storied history, but a focused analysis of its present state, capturing the complex feelings of a dedicated community navigating a mature, ever-evolving world. Players report a mix of awe for its foundational strengths and growing concern over its future direction, making the current moment a pivotal one for the franchise.

What keeps players logging in after all these years?

Even after eight years, the universal consensus among players is that Destiny 2's gunplay is in a class of its own. The moment-to-moment experience of aiming down sights, unleashing a torrent of elemental energy, and chaining abilities into a symphony of destruction is described as nothing short of sublime. This core combat loop is the game's unshakeable foundation. Recent discussions are filled with praise for the intricate build-crafting systems, which allow for a staggering degree of personalization. Players report immense satisfaction in fine-tuning their Guardian's armor, weapons, and abilities to create powerful, synergistic builds that can dominate the battlefield. Whether it's a perfectly timed grenade throw that clears a room or a precision shot that fells a colossal boss, the game consistently delivers thrilling feedback that makes every encounter feel impactful. This satisfying combat is the gravitational force that, according to many, holds the entire experience together, compelling veterans to return and providing a powerful hook for those just starting their journey.

Is the new 'Edge of Fate' expansion enough?

The release of 'The Edge of Fate' 25 days ago was met with high expectations, but community reception has been decidedly mixed. While the new environments are often praised for their stunning art direction—a consistent high point for the series—many players express disappointment with the substance of the content itself. A common sentiment found in recent online forums and social media is that the expansion's campaign feels brief and its narrative developments are less impactful than hoped. Furthermore, players describe the new gameplay loop and endgame activities as feeling overly familiar and repetitive, relying on established formulas rather than introducing bold new ideas. There are widespread reports of frustration with the perceived value proposition, with many feeling the new content doesn't provide enough meaningful or lasting engagement to justify the grind, a sentiment that weighs heavily on the game's Content & Immersion score.

What is the state of the Guardian community?

For a game built on cooperative play, the health of its social systems is paramount, and this is where current player sentiment signals the most significant concerns. The lowest-scoring aspect of the recent experience, the community and social features are a major point of contention. Veteran players and newcomers alike report that the in-game tools for finding fireteams for high-level activities remain cumbersome and inefficient. The reliance on external, third-party apps for group-finding is a long-standing issue that many feel should have been addressed within the game itself by now. Recent discussions also highlight a challenging new-player experience, with many feeling that the game does a poor job of onboarding Guardians into its complex web of systems and lore. This creates a sense of disconnect and frustration, making it difficult for the community to feel truly united. There's a palpable feeling among players that the social infrastructure is lagging behind the quality of the core gameplay, creating unnecessary friction in a game that should be all about connection and teamwork.

How does Destiny 2 look and feel in 2025?

Visually, Destiny 2 continues to be a spectacle. The art team's ability to craft breathtaking skyboxes, awe-inspiring alien architecture, and detailed weapon models remains a source of constant praise within the community. The game's aesthetic is iconic and has aged remarkably well. However, beneath this polished surface, players report a growing sense of technical and innovative stagnation. While the game runs well, there's a perception that the underlying engine is being pushed to its limits, preventing more ambitious advancements in physics, enemy AI, or environmental interactivity. This feeling extends to mission design, which many players find has settled into a predictable rhythm. The lack of significant evolution in the core activity structure has led to a sense of 'more of the same,' leaving a portion of the player base hungry for genuine innovation. As the community looks ahead to the 'Renegades' expansion slated for December, there is a collective hope that it will not only advance the story but also push the game's technical and design boundaries, injecting a fresh dose of novelty into this established universe.

Category Analysis

Core Experience

6.38

The fundamental gameplay experience including fun factor, mechanics, and technical performance.

The core experience is defined by a strong foundation of enjoyable combat and buildcrafting, but this is significantly hampered by widespread technical instability and persistent player frustrations with repetitive grind and unclear progression systems.

Content & Immersion

5.79

Story quality, world depth, replay value, and overall content value.

Players are deeply invested in the game's rich narrative and world, but the overall experience is marked by inconsistency in content pacing, repetitive activities, and mixed perceptions of the game's monetary value.

Presentation & Innovation

6.01

Visual and audio quality combined with creative and innovative design elements.

The game's presentation is praised for its strong art direction and creative gameplay ideas, but this is tempered by recurring audio-visual bugs and a sentiment that innovation can feel inconsistent or underdeveloped.

Community & Social

5.41

Multiplayer features, social aspects, and developer support systems.

While players enjoy the core cooperative gameplay, the social experience is undermined by persistent matchmaking problems and a widespread feeling that developer communication is lacking in transparency and responsiveness to community feedback.

Pros

  • Exceptional moment-to-moment gunplay and combat feel remain best-in-class.
  • Stunning art direction and world design continue to impress.
  • Deep build-crafting systems offer satisfying combat synergy and player expression.

Cons

  • Recent content updates are perceived by many players as repetitive and lacking in narrative weight.
  • Core social and matchmaking systems are reported as feeling outdated and cumbersome.
  • A sense of technical and innovative stagnation is a growing community concern.

True-Review™ Datapoints Analysis

Our True-Review is based on 10 datapoints collected over multiple days. Each datapoint is scored and weighted according to its importance. These weighted scores are then averaged to calculate the final True-Review score.

Fun Factor

Weight:
350
Score:
7.07

Pure enjoyment and entertainment value of playing the game.

Players find significant enjoyment in the game's foundational combat and the freedom to experiment with diverse character builds, especially with new options introduced in the recent 'The Edge of Fate' expansion. The core loop of shooting, looting, and customizing remains a powerful draw for the community. However, this enjoyment is often undercut by long-standing frustrations with the repetitive nature of endgame activities and the grind required for rewards. Some players also feel that certain design choices and complex new systems detract from the pure fun, creating a divided experience between exhilarating action and tedious progression.

Core Gameplay Mechanics

Weight:
100
Score:
5.47

Quality of primary gameplay systems including combat, controls, and core interaction loops.

The game's moment-to-moment gunplay and deep character customization are consistently praised by the community as best-in-class, forming a strong and satisfying foundation. Players love the feel of the combat and the creative potential in crafting unique builds. This praise is tempered by significant frustration with the game's progression systems, which many find opaque and unrewarding for the time invested. Recent content has also introduced complaints about overly resilient enemies and complex new mechanics that lack adequate in-game explanation, making the experience feel more like a chore than a challenge.

Technical Performance

Weight:
100
Score:
4.88

Game stability, optimization, frame rate, bugs, and overall technical execution.

While the game's core engine can feel smooth and responsive when functioning correctly, the overall technical state is a major source of player frustration. Widespread reports detail persistent instability, including frequent game crashes across all platforms, with a notable spike on PlayStation consoles following recent updates. Players also consistently encounter performance hitches like frame rate drops in demanding activities and a variety of disruptive bugs, such as persistent audio glitches. These ongoing technical problems significantly detract from the gameplay experience, overshadowing the game's otherwise solid performance foundation.

Content Quality & Pacing

Weight:
125
Score:
5.72

Overall quality of story, world-building, characters, and narrative pacing across all content.

The community generally holds the game's narrative, character arcs, and deep lore in high regard, finding the world immersive and the story from the recent 'The Edge of Fate' expansion engaging. Players are invested in the universe and its ongoing development. However, this narrative quality is often undermined by inconsistent content pacing, with many activities feeling repetitive or artificially drawn out to increase playtime. There is also a strong sentiment that while the story is good, the game needs more fresh, substantial gameplay activities to accompany it, as some new systems feel complex without adding meaningful depth.

Replay Value & Longevity

Weight:
75
Score:
6.07

Amount of content, replayability factors, and long-term engagement potential.

The game's strong core gameplay and deep character customization provide a solid foundation for replayability, keeping many players engaged over the long term. However, sentiment indicates that this longevity is being tested by persistent issues. Players express concern over the repetitive nature of the endgame grind and the increasing complexity of game systems without clear, rewarding long-term goals. The community's continued interest seems contingent on the developers addressing these pain points and providing more accessible and compelling reasons to keep playing beyond the initial campaign.

Value & Monetization

Weight:
50
Score:
5.57

Price-to-content ratio, DLC value, microtransaction fairness, and overall monetary value.

Player perception of the game's monetary value is decidedly mixed, creating a split in the community. Many players feel the volume of content and the quality of the core experience, including the recent 'The Edge of Fate' expansion, justify the cost. Conversely, a significant portion of the player base expresses concerns about the high price of entry for new expansions and the perceived fairness of the in-game store and progression systems. This division highlights an ongoing debate about whether the content provided adequately matches the financial investment required to stay current.

Visual & Audio Quality

Weight:
60
Score:
6.08

Combined assessment of graphics, art style, sound design, music, and overall presentation.

The game's presentation is widely praised for its stunning art direction, unique aesthetic, and evocative musical score, which work together to create a highly immersive world. Players frequently commend the visual design of new locations and gear introduced in content like 'The Edge of Fate'. This artistic success is unfortunately held back by persistent technical flaws that disrupt the experience. Recurring issues such as visual glitches, screen tearing, and various audio bugs—like sound dropping out or looping incorrectly—prevent the presentation from being consistently excellent.

Innovation & Creativity

Weight:
40
Score:
5.90

Originality, fresh ideas, creative design elements, and innovative approaches to gameplay or presentation.

The community acknowledges and often appreciates the developers' efforts to introduce innovative concepts, such as new combat mechanics and creative ability systems that expand build diversity. Narrative choices and unique design elements in recent content are frequently highlighted as positive steps forward. However, this appreciation is balanced by a feeling that some innovations are hampered by cumbersome implementation or are wrapped in the same repetitive activity structures. Players express a desire for more consistently bold and polished updates that feel genuinely fresh, rather than just adding complexity to existing formulas.

Multiplayer & Social Features

Weight:
60
Score:
6.10

Quality of multiplayer gameplay, social features, community interaction, and online experiences.

The cooperative nature of the game remains a major draw, with players valuing the experience of tackling challenging content with others and appreciating the ability to find groups for most activities. However, the systems that support this multiplayer experience are a significant source of friction. Players consistently report frustration with poor matchmaking in competitive modes, leading to unbalanced teams and long queue times. Furthermore, the in-game group-finding tools are often described as clunky and less efficient than third-party alternatives, indicating a need for modernization of the game's social infrastructure.

Developer Support

Weight:
40
Score:
4.37

Developer communication, update frequency, bug fixes, and overall post-launch support quality.

While the community acknowledges the regular delivery of new content and system updates, there is widespread frustration regarding the quality and frequency of developer communication. Players express a strong desire for more transparency and proactivity in addressing community feedback, particularly concerning persistent bugs, balance issues, and confusing progression paths. The sentiment suggests a feeling that developers are not responsive enough to ongoing problems or clear enough in explaining their design intent. This perceived communication gap creates friction and leaves many players feeling unheard.

Score Tinkering Tool

You can look at the scores and weights and make adjustments to see where we derive the final from. Tinker, play, test and above all else - have fun!

Open Score Tinkerer
Comments (0)
Please log in to post a comment.
Loading comments...

True-Review™ Methodology

Our reviews are based on comprehensive datapoint analysis collected over multiple days of community feedback and gameplay data. Each datapoint is scored and weighted according to its importance in the overall experience.

Learn more about our methodology

Destiny 2

Final Score:6.10
Analysis Period:45 days
Analysis Timespan:25-JUN-25 - 09-AUG-25
Data Sources:89,826
Review Date:09-AUG-25
© 2025 Soren Enterprises
AboutPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service